Overview
We use a variety of methods for content sharing and Publishing at SCVi. Within the school, Facilitators, Learners, and Staff need to share documents and Media. Outside the school, we publish content for consumption by Parents, Learners, Staff, and the public. With the transition to Google apps for education, we have the opportunity to consolidate many of these things under the scvi-k12 domain. We also want to take a close look at which publish methods can be found by web crawlers for search engines. The purpose of this posting is to give some background and discuss options on how this might work.What We Do Now
Internally
Internally, we mostly deal with sharing content. Here are some of the most common methods.- Drop Box : Documents shared between teachers and students
- Flash Drives : Most Learners and Facilitators carry Flash Drives for document and content sharing as well.
- E-Mail : File Attachments and discussions
- Network Attached Storage : Video and picture sharing.
- Google Docs : This is done on an ad-hoc bases using student's own e-mail addresses.
Externally
Externally, we are mostly focused on sharing information with staff, teachers, parents and the public. Here are some of the methods that are used.- GoDaddy Web Site : The main school web site has a great deal of information
- Ed Line : Student grades, Attendance, and Assignments
- Yammer : Staff Discussions
- Constant Contact : Parent/Staff E-Mail Notifications (Monday Message)
- BlackBoard Connect : Parent/Staff Email and Phone Notifications
- Google Groups : Discussions and E-Mail Lists
- Wix Web Pages: Communication to Parents and student projects (Example, Example, Example, Example)
- Prezi Web Pages : Learners sharing content with Parents, Peers, and Facilitators (Example, Example, Example, Example)
- Google Docs : Communication to parents, Student Work
- Facebook : Discussions, Photo Sharing (Example, Example, Example)
- Picasa Web Albums : Photo Sharing (Example)
- Shutterfly : Photo Sharing (Example)
- Google You Tube : Video Sharing. (Example)
Focusing On Web Content
If you focus just on the Outward Facing web content, many publish methods can be grouped into these high level organizations.- Documents : Information organized by topic.
- Blogs : One person speaking to an audience in chronological fashion.
- Discussions : Back and forth discussion between people. Can be chat or e-mail.
- Photo/Video Sharing/Albums : Really, just another kind of document.
- Tasks, Planning : Calendars, To Do Lists, Events
Service | Documents | Blogs | Discussions/ | Photo/Video Sharing/Albums | Tasks, Planning, Calendar | Custom Web Site | Friends, Networks, Connections |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Google Docs | Blogger | Google Groups, GMail | Picasa Albums, YouTube | Google Calendar, Google Tasks | Google Sites | Google+, Google Groups | |
No | Wall Postings | Chat, Postings, Messages | Google Albums | FB Events | No | Yes | |
Jive SBS | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Tasks | No | Yes |
MyBigCampus | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | Yes |
Moodle | ? | ? | Yes | ? | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Yammer | No | No | Yes | Pages | No | No | Yes |
Edline | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? |
Joomla | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? |
GoDaddy | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | ? | Yes | ? |
Wix | Sharing | Yes | No | No | No | Almost | No |
Word Press | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Looking At Google
With the transition to Google apps for education, we have the opportunity to consolidate many of these things. Though, we want to strike a balance between flexibility, searchability and consistency. It is still yet unclear where things will land. Though, here is a first pass at some of our ideas.Scenario (Use Case) | Google Solution | Other Solutions We May Use |
---|---|---|
Facilitator Web Site, School Web Site | Google Sites | Edline, Others TBD *** |
Learner, Staff, Facilitator E-Mail | G-Mail * | - |
Mail Lists, E-Mail Notifications, Discussions | Google Groups | Blackboard, Yammer, Constant Contact |
Calendar | Google Calendar | - |
Generic File Sharing | - | Drop Box, Ubuntu One |
Documents | Google Docs | Open Office, MS Office, iWork |
Tasks, Planning | Google Tasks | Trello |
Photo/Video Sharing | Picasa, YouTube | |
Social Networking | - ** | Facebook, My Big Campus |
Student grades, Attendance, and Assignments | - | EdLine |
* With POP and IMAP support, some folks may not know they are using G-Mail.
** Google Plus is not included in Google Apps For Education
*** We don't want to be too prescriptive. If someone has a passion for a certain technology, they should be free to try it out.
It seems to me if you are looking for consistency on some respects whilst still allowing folks to choose something else if they so desire and feel comfortable. With that, I would have to recommend Google as well. I don't have experience with Wix or EdLine but Wordpress is first and foremost designed to be a blog--everything else is just extra. I don't think WP is the solution for everyone by default, but it is easy enough to setup that if someone wanted to have a blog with a lot more customization than say blogspot for example, they could.
ReplyDeleteI like the collaboration that Google provides in its tools. Frankly, I've not seen another platform (desktop, online, or otherwise) come close to that. Education is about learning and collaborating with others as part of that journey. I once read an interesting blog post by the Google Docs team about how a teacher used it in his/her classroom: http://googledocs.blogspot.com/2008/03/teachers-has-google-docs-changed-how.html
They've even provided another post with some recommendations:
http://googledocs.blogspot.com/2010/02/google-docs-tool-for-21st-century.html
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteGreat summary Matt!
ReplyDeleteWordPress is great as a CMS and has MU functions that can solve every issue. It would allow for one admin area to manage everything.
Check out this plugin: http://buddypress.org/community/groups/buddypress-courseware/
Whatever the team decides, keep in mind that it should be open-source and self-hosted. Not having choice in data centers and not being able to modify design and tinker with the code will limit future customization.
If it is true open-source, like WordPress, then the answer is always "yes, it can do that". It then just comes down to time and/or money to make it happen.